| March
10, 2002, Sunday
MONEY AND BUSINESS/FINANCIAL DESK
Investing; Day Trading Takes a Conservative Turn
By DAN COLARUSSO (NYT) 1268 words
EVEN at the height of the bull market, Lowell Koppel
did not fit the mold of the hyperactive day trader who
jumped in and out of technology stocks dozens of times
a day. Instead, he relied on evenhanded options strategies
to generate consistent returns that had little to do
with the Internet stock bubble.
Maybe that is why, after two years of stock market
declines, Mr. Koppel, 66, a former software executive,
is still trading 100 times a month. Last year, he
said, his trading returned 11.5 percent. ''I'm a conservative
investor,'' he said from his home in Winchester, Mass.
''I only use about 25 percent of my assets to do this
stuff with. The rest is in bonds.''
Day trading became a prominent part of the market
landscape in the late 1990's as individual investors
using online trading technology left their day jobs
and leveraged their nest eggs to trade stocks, often
jumping in and out of positions within minutes. The
market downturn that began in early 2000 thinned these
ranks by the thousands and forced out of business
many firms that had provided traders with training,
trading privileges and technology.
Many of the individual traders who remain have adopted
relatively conservative approaches. They say they
are holding positions longer, using less aggressive
strategies, diversifying their holdings and relying
more on short-selling, the practice of borrowing shares
to sell in the hope of buying them back later at a
lower price.
''In the old days it was, 'Buy whatever you can
afford and go home happy,' '' said Joseph Cammarata,
president of Sonic Trading, a day-trading firm in
New York. ''Now, you have to try to preserve capital.''
Michael Parness, 38, who runs TrendFund.com, which
dispenses trading advice online, said, ''I think the
main difference is that you have to be willing to
take less.'' The title of Mr. Parness's new book,
''Rule the Freakin' Markets'' (St. Martin's Press),
shows that his confidence has not waned. He does,
however, remind investors to take the same pleasure
in buying and selling Goldman Sachs shares at a $2.50
profit as they once did in playing Juniper Networks
for one-day gains of $30 a share.
''Everyone who's trading now is actually doing this
for a living,'' said Don Bright, the head of Bright
Trading, a day-trading firm with 42 offices and 600
clients in the United States. ''The people who treated
it like selling real estate on the weekends are gone.''
Mr. Koppel, who has been trading for three years,
said he had never been comfortable with pure stock
trading. Trained as a chemical engineer, he gravitated
to the complex math of options and spends days analyzing
them for potential mispricings.
''It's really only in the last six months that I've
gotten my calculations to the point where I feel confident,''
Mr. Koppel said, adding that he gets most of his income
from writing covered calls, a conservative strategy
that involves buying stock and selling call options.
The strategy sacrifices potential appreciation in
the shares for guaranteed income from the sale of
the options.
The confidence was tested when the market was near
its peaks, Mr. Koppel said. ''Sometimes I felt bad
because the stock indices were performing so well
and the opportunity loss was large. Now, though, I
just try to consistently make money and not worry
about the indices.''
Teresa Appleton-Lutz, 37, began trading five years
ago after leaving a job at Hewlett-Packard to care
for her two children. She has moved from trading initial
offerings and technology stocks that were so fashionable
in 1999 to trading futures contracts.
''It was so easy to find something to trade then,''
Ms. Appleton-Lutz said. For seven months, she said,
she traded only three stocks, Ciena, Exxon Mobil and
Mercury Interactive, a strategy that was successful
until the market changed.
Now she takes comfort in trading E-mini futures,
contracts based on major indexes like the Standard
& Poor's 500 or the Nasdaq 100 but sliced into smaller
pieces for individual investors, and in reading books
on charting, technical analysis and more sophisticated
techniques. ''When you trade futures on the market,
you don't have to worry about a biotech company saying
the F.D.A. is investigating it,'' she said. ''You
don't have to sweat that kind of stuff. You want to
live to trade another day.''
While their numbers have dwindled, active traders
are prized by securities firms, which cater to their
needs. Electronic trading systems -- often called
direct-access trading -- have become widely available
to those who want to trade often, but not necessarily
at the pace of the day traders of the Internet boom.
Some of the biggest companies in the online brokerage
business, like Charles Schwab, Ameritrade and E*Trade,
have taken steps to increase offerings for active
traders in order to diversify their own revenue mix.
In early 2000, Schwab acquired CyberCorp, a direct-access
trading firm, and renamed it CyberTrader. Since the
takeover, the firm's active-trader roll has swelled
to 10,000 from 2,500, Schwab executives say. That
has helped the company weather a slump in the broader
online trading business. Schwab added just 47,000
accounts in the fourth quarter of 2001, down from
its peak of 359,000 in the first quarter of 2000;
new accounts at Ameritrade dropped to 35,000 from
306,000 over the same period, according to a report
from Putnam Lovell, an investment bank in San Francisco.
E*Trade licensed direct-access software from A.
B. Watley, a day-trading firm, and Ameritrade uses
direct-access software developed by TradeCast, another
firm with day-trading roots.
''Active traders still are a very important part
of the business,'' said Richard Repetto, an e-finance
analyst at Putnam Lovell. ''They're a small part of
the customer base, but they are very profitable.''
Mr. Repetto said CyberTrader clients account for
13,500 of the 155,000 trades done ''on an average
day'' through Charles Schwab. Considering that the
firm has 7.5 million clients, the trades by the 10,000
at CyberTrader represent a significant chunk of business.
''Active trading is a viable piece of a big firm
with a vertical strategy'' that includes services
beyond direct-access capability, said Gary Mednick,
an executive vice president at A. B. Watley and former
head of OnSite Trading, a day-trading shop. ''The
top 10 percent of traders is still producing 90 percent
of the business'' for brokerage firms.
BETH STELLUTO, a senior vice president for active-trader
sales and marketing at Schwab, said company studies
showed that active traders use just 37 percent of
their investable assets for trading. A few years ago,
it was not uncommon for day traders to mortgage their
homes to raise trading capital.
The industry regards the shift as positive, because
it indicates that traders will withstand future market
shocks better than they did the bursting of the Internet
bubble.
Still, Mr. Bright, whose firm trades 20 million
to 30 million shares a day, said re-educating traders
as the market fell had rated a 7 out of 10 on a scale
of difficulty.
''You have to remind people not to be headstrong,
so you can't limit yourself to buying first; you can
short,'' he said. ''You can't keep doing something
that doesn't work. There were people just holding
stock and praying it would go up.''
|